[8/25 CFM] Classification!

In yesterday’s community feedback meeting, we discussed possible improvements to the classification system.

Attendees: @Anurag_Katyal @Charles_Nykamp @Duane_Nykamp1 @Melissa_Lynn

Community feedback meetings run every two weeks and are open to everyone, brand-new folks included. The next meeting will be at:

Possible improvements to the categories

It’s become clear from this thread that the mode category is confusing and is doing too much. In the meeting, we came up with an alternative:

Goals (1 or more)

  • introduce
  • practice
  • assess

Mode (1 or more)

  • game/puzzle
  • exploration
  • demonstration
  • problem(s)/exercise(s)

Also, some tweaks to scope:

Scope (select 1)

  • standalone activity – you can give this to students
  • problem (or exercise?) – combine this with other exercises and give to students
  • widget – not pedagogical, meant to be a component in an activity

(and widget shouldn’t ask for goal or mode)

Possible improvements to math topic classification

Right now, categorizing the math topic is a hurdle to making an activity public. There are two aspects to this: 1) what granularity do we require? 2) how do we ask authors to classify their activity?

Some potential ideas we discussed:

  • only require the top level e.g., “Trigonometry” (?)
  • streamline the process into fewer clicks
  • front-load the question when authors first create an activity (?)

For tomorrow’s community feedback meeting, here are a few other topics we could discuss along with the above classifications:

  1. How folder navigation should work.
  2. Improving auto numbering, especially with <part> or <task>.
  3. Do we want an easy way to put content between an answer blank and its check work button.
  4. Feedback on new components just appearing on the dev version. (Use at your own risk because they may be evolving):
    • <argMax>
    • <argMin>
    • <binCounts>
    • <chart>
    • <cumulativeMax>
    • <cumulativeMin>
    • <cumulativeProduct>
    • <cumulativeSum>
    • <differences>
    • <indexOf>
    • <sampleMultivariateRandomNumber>
    • <searchSorted>
    • <sortIndices>
    • <summaryStatistics>
    • <tally>

Hope to see you tomorrow! Zoom link and time are in the original message, above.

Blarg. I can’t make it to today’s meeting but this sounds like very relevant stuff.