Radical Oddities

Variant a (nth root): The 5th root of a^33 is not being simplified as part of the problem but it is being simplified correctly when it is by itself.

Variant c (nth root): Issues with a and f

Variant d (nth root): Issues with b and g

Similar problems with other variants as well.

<section boxed>
  <title>Square Root</title>

  <setup>
    
    <select name="k">2 3 5 6 7 10</select> 
    
    <selectFromSequence
      name="sq"
      from="2"
      to="15"
    /> 
    
    <selectFromSequence
      name="var"
      type="letters"
      numToSelect="3"
      sort
      exclude="e i"
    /> 
    
    <selectFromSequence name="power" from="0" to="35" numToSelect="3" />
  </setup>

  <p>k=$k, sq=$sq</p>
  <p>var1=$var[1], power1=$power[1]</p>
  <p>var2=$var[2], power2=$power[2]</p>
  <p>var3=$var[3], power3=$power[3]</p>


  Simplify
  <math simplify="numbersPreserveOrder">
     sqrt($k*$sq^2*$var[1]^$power[1]*$var[2]^$power[2]*$var[3]^$power[3])
  </math>

  <p>
    Solution:
    <math simplify assumptions="$var[1] > 0 and $var[2] > 0 and $var[3] > 0">
       sqrt($k*$sq^2*$var[1]^$power[1]*$var[2]^$power[2]*$var[3]^$power[3])
    </math>
  </p>

  <p>
    Part 1:
    <math simplify assumptions="$var[1] > 0 and $var[2] > 0 and $var[3] > 0">
       sqrt($k*$sq^2)
    </math>
  </p>

  <p>
    Part 2:
    <math simplify assumptions="$var[1] > 0 and $var[2] > 0 and $var[3] > 0">
       sqrt($var[1]^$power[1])
    </math>
  </p>

  <p>
    Part 3:
    <math simplify assumptions="$var[1] > 0 and $var[2] > 0 and $var[3] > 0">
       sqrt($var[2]^$power[2])
    </math>
  </p>

  <p>
    Part 4:
    <math simplify assumptions="$var[1] > 0 and $var[2] > 0 and $var[3] > 0">
       sqrt($var[3]^$power[3])
    </math>
  </p>
</section>

<section boxed>
  <title>Cube Root</title>

  <setup>
    <select name="k">2 3 5 6 7 10</select> 
    
    <selectFromSequence
      name="cube"
      from="2"
      to="7"
    /> 
    
    <selectFromSequence name="var" type="letters" numToSelect="3" sort exclude="e i"></selectFromSequence>
    
    <selectFromSequence
      name="power"
      from="0"
      to="35"
      numToSelect="3"
    />
  </setup>

  <p>k=$k, cube=$cube</p>
  <p>var1=$var[1], power1=$power[1]</p>
  <p>var2=$var[2], power2=$power[2]</p>
  <p>var3=$var[3], power3=$power[3]</p>


  Simplify
  <math simplify="numbersPreserveOrder">
     cbrt($k*$cube^3*$var[1]^$power[1]*$var[2]^$power[2]*$var[3]^$power[3])
  </math>

  <p>
    Solution:
    <math simplify assumptions="$var[1] > 0 and $var[2] > 0 and $var[3] > 0">
       cbrt($k*$cube^3*$var[1]^($power[1])*$var[2]^($power[2])*$var[3]^($power[3]))

    </math>
  </p>

  <p>
    Part 1:
    <math simplify assumptions="$var[1] > 0 and $var[2] > 0 and $var[3] > 0">
       cbrt($k*$cube^3)
    </math>
  </p>

  <p>
    Part 2:
    <math simplify assumptions="$var[1] > 0 and $var[2] > 0 and $var[3] > 0">
       cbrt($var[1]^($power[1]))
    </math>
  </p>

  <p>
    Part 3:
    <math simplify assumptions="$var[1] > 0 and $var[2] > 0 and $var[3] > 0">
       cbrt($var[2]^($power[2]))
    </math>
  </p>

  <p>
    Part 4:
    <math simplify assumptions="$var[1] > 0 and $var[2] > 0 and $var[3] > 0">
       cbrt($var[3]^($power[3]))
    </math>
  </p>
</section>

<section boxed>
  <title>nth Root</title>

  <setup>
     <select name="k">2 3 5 6 7 10</select> 
    <selectFromSequence
      name="nthRoot"
      from="2"
      to="3"
    /> 
    <selectFromSequence name="index" from="4" to="7" /> 
    
    <selectFromSequence
      name="var"
      type="letters"
      numToSelect="3"
      sort
      exclude="e i"
    /> 
    
    <selectFromSequence name="power" from="0" to="35" numToSelect="3" />
  </setup>

  <p>k=$k, nthRoot=$nthRoot, index=$index</p>
  <p>var1=$var[1], power1=$power[1]</p>
  <p>var2=$var[2], power2=$power[2]</p>
  <p>var3=$var[3], power3=$power[3]</p>


  Simplify
  <math simplify="numbersPreserveOrder">
     nthroot($k*$nthRoot^$index*$var[1]^($power[1])*$var[2]^($power[2])*$var[3]^($power[3]),
    $index)
  </math>

  <p>
    Solution:
    <math simplify assumptions="$var[1] > 0 and $var[2] > 0 and $var[3] > 0">
       nthroot($k*$nthRoot^$index * $var[1]^($power[1])*$var[2]^($power[2])*$var[3]^($power[3]),
      $index)
    </math>
  </p>

  <p>
    Part 1:
    <math simplify assumptions="$var[1] > 0 and $var[2] > 0 and $var[3] > 0">
       nthroot(($k*$nthRoot^$index), $index)
    </math>
  </p>

  <p>
    Part 2:
    <math simplify assumptions="$var[1] > 0 and $var[2] > 0 and $var[3] > 0">
       nthroot($var[1]^($power[1]), $index)
    </math>
  </p>

  <p>
    Part 3:
    <math simplify assumptions="$var[1] > 0 and $var[2] > 0 and $var[3] > 0">
       nthroot($var[2]^($power[2]), $index)
    </math>
  </p>

  <p>
    Part 4:
    <math simplify assumptions="$var[1] > 0 and $var[2] > 0 and $var[3] > 0">
       nthroot($var[3]^($power[3]), $index)
    </math>
  </p>
</section>

This is weird.

If we have

<math simplify assumptions="a > 0 and b > 0 and c > 0">
     nthroot(a^(7)*b^(6)*c^(27), 5)
</math>

it correctly simplifies to abc^5*nthroot(a^(2)*b*c^(2), 5).

However, if we have

<math simplify assumptions="a > 0 and b > 0 and c > 0">
     nthroot(a^(7)*b^(6)*c^(28), 5)
</math>

then it gives up at c^5*nthroot(a^(7)*b^(6)*c^(3), 5).

Is the moral that Doenet gets scared with too big of numbers?

No, it’s not size. a^(7)*b^(6)*c^(7) is OK, but a^(7)*b^(6)*c^(8) breaks it again until a^(7)*b^(6)*c^(10) is fine again.

I couldn’t come up with anything consistent for circumstances when things were breaking.

I opened a bug report.

New dev version of DoenetML fixes this bug.